Ten people, Rs 20,000 each, every month, for ten months. One person takes the whole Rs 200,000 each month, and everybody eventually gets a turn. It is one of the most common savings arrangements in South Asia and one of the most reliably mis-recorded, because from a bank statement’s point of view it looks like nine months of heavy spending and one month of winning a small lottery.
What a committee actually is
Strip away the social layer and a committee — a BC, a chit fund, a ROSCA, a susu, a tanda, depending on where you are — is a savings scheme with a queue. Everyone puts in the same amount; everyone takes out the same total; the only thing that differs is when.
If you take the first payout you have effectively borrowed interest-free from the others. If you take the last, you have lent to them. The middle is roughly neutral. Nothing about the arrangement generates money — it moves the timing of money that already existed.
The short answer
A contribution is money moved, not money spent. You have swapped cash for a claim on the pot. Your net position is unchanged the moment after you pay in.
The exception, and it is a real one, is default. If a member stops paying and the pot comes up short, the part you never get back is a genuine loss — and that is the moment to record an expense, for the amount that is actually gone.
The payout is not income
This is the half people get wrong even after they have got the contributions right, and it produces the more dramatic error of the two.
| If you record it as | The payout month shows | What is true |
|---|---|---|
| Income | Rs 200,000 of earnings | Rs 0 earned — it is your own money arriving |
| A transfer from the committee account | Nothing in income or spending | Correct |
The consequences are worse than they look. A single Rs 200,000 line recorded as income inflates that month’s earnings, distorts your savings rate for the month, and then poisons any year-on-year comparison — because next year the same month will look like a catastrophic decline in income.
Tracking one in Rakama
The method is the same one that works for cash, applied to a different kind of place money can sit.
- Create an account for the committee. Type it as Savings; the balance starts at zero.
- Each monthly contribution is a transfer from your current account into it.
- When your turn arrives, the payout is a transfer out of it, back into current.
- If the pot fails and you are short, record that shortfall — and only that — as an expense.
What this buys you is a balance that answers the question people actually have, which is how much am I into this thing for? Five months in, the account says Rs 100,000, and that number is visible next to your bank balances rather than living in your head.
One thing to be aware of
After the payout the account returns to zero and then goes negative as you keep contributing for the remaining months — because you now owe the group your remaining turns. Rakama will hold a negative balance without complaint, and negative is the honest number: it is what you are still committed to paying in.
There is no committee feature, no schedule, and nothing that knows when your turn is. The account is a container and the discipline is yours. For an arrangement this simple that is genuinely enough — what it needs is somewhere to accumulate, not automation.
Frequently asked questions
Is a committee or BC contribution an expense?
No. You are putting money into a pot you have a claim on, so it is closer to a transfer into savings than to spending.
Is the committee payout income?
No. It is your own contributions coming back, plus or minus the timing advantage of where you sat in the queue. Recording it as income can make one month look like you doubled your salary.
How do I track a committee?
Make an account for it, transfer each monthly contribution into it, and transfer the payout back out when your turn arrives. The account balance is what you have in.
What if someone defaults?
That is the point at which real money is genuinely lost, and it is the only part of a committee that is a true expense. Write off the shortfall as spending when it becomes clear it is not coming back.
Make your money easier to understand.
Track expenses, plan budgets, and keep your goals in one clear view with Rakama.
Try Rakama free ↗